Who Pays for Damage to a Rental Car Accident in Florida?
Newman Injury Law, PLLC is committed to helping injured Floridians get the compensation they deserve, every step of the way.
Written/Reviewed by:
Jared K. Newman Esq.
Last Updated - September 30, 2026
Read Time - Est: 5 minutes
If you own a vehicle, you may already be familiar with liability laws and policies for car accidents in Florida. But what happens if you get into an accident in a rental car? Who will be responsible for the damages to the rental car? What about the other car? You are probably concerned about how much it will cost to make repairs to a car that you don’t even own. Fortunately, we can provide answers to all of your questions on this subject.
Car rental companies are typically not responsible for damages caused by accidents. Not only will they avoid liability for damages to their own rental car, but they also likely won’t be liable for the damages to other cars either. If you are involved in a car accident with a rental car, chances are that one of the two drivers will be liable. In most cases, the party that will ultimately end up paying is one of the insurance companies. The only instance in which the rental company will be liable is if they were negligent in maintaining the rental car and that negligence caused the accident.
Regardless of the surrounding circumstances, you should always have the help of a Hollywood, FL car accident attorney after being involved in a crash. The dedicated Florida car accident lawyers at Newman Injury Law are ready to help you assess your legal options regarding damages from a rental car accident in Florida. To schedule your first consultation for free, call our offices at 954-495-8500.
Insurance Requirements for Rental Cars in Florida
Florida law requires that every single person who gets behind the wheel of a car have at least some level of insurance coverage. Personal vehicle owners in Florida all must have personal injury protection coverage, which is intended to cover the damage to your own car in an accident as well as roughly 80% of medical expenses incurred in the accident.
If you have personal injury protection (PIP) coverage because you own a car, but you were driving a rental car in Florida when you got into an accident, your insurance will usually still apply to the damages to the rental car. Your PIP coverage is intended to apply to you as a driver generally, not just to you as a driver of your own car.
Florida citizens are not legally permitted to rent a car without insurance. If you do not have personal injury protection coverage, Florida law requires that car rental companies supply you with a sufficient coverage plan before handing over the keys. One way or another, if you are involved in an accident while driving a rental car, insurance will most likely cover the damages to the car.
What Does Rental Car Insurance Cover in Florida?
Whether insurance will cover damages that you caused as a result of your own negligence behind the wheel of a rental car will depend on the language of your coverage plan. Some insurance plans will cover a driver for accidents caused by negligent actions like speeding or other traffic violations but won’t cover damages caused by more reckless conduct like drunk driving. If you are concerned about the fine print of your plan or have been denied coverage, speak to one of our Miami car accident attorneys immediately. We can go through the insurance policy line-by-line to make sure that you aren’t being mistreated by the company that exists primarily to protect you.
If another driver’s negligence causes an accident that damages your rental vehicle, you will be responsible for the damages unless you file a claim with the other driver’s insurance company. If your claim is denied or the insurance representative offers you less than you deserve, you should speak to an experienced Hallandale Beach car accident attorney as soon as possible. Claims can lapse, and you shouldn’t be left holding the bag for damages that you didn’t cause to a car that you don’t even own.
Are Rental Car Companies Responsible for Vehicle Damage and Injuries in Florida?
Almost every rental car company will require you to sign a waiver that relieves them of responsibility for any property damage or injuries from a car accident. These agreements typically contain strong, effective language that frees the company from responsibility. Ultimately, you (and your insurance provider) will likely be responsible for damages to the rental car that you caused.
The only exception that may apply is where the rental car company’s mistakes caused the accident and the damages. Rental car companies owe a duty to their customers to properly maintain the vehicles and ensure that they are safe to drive when they leave the lot. Maintenance mistakes or equipment failure might lead to an accident, putting the driver in danger that they didn’t expect.
For instance, if the rental car company failed to perform reasonable inspections on their cars to confirm that all vehicles had functioning brake lines, they would have breached their duty to their customers. Thus, if a customer’s vehicle malfunctioned while braking and caused an accident with another car, the negligent car rental company should be liable for the damages that resulted from the accident, in which case you’ll want to contact a Pembroke Pines car accident lawyer.
We Can Help with Rental Car Accident Damages in Florida
Newman Injury Law helps victims negotiate with insurance companies and assess their options after an accident involving a rental car. Call our Aventura car accident attorneys for a free initial consultation on your options. We can be reached at 954-495-8500.
- 1 Over Fifteen Years of Florida Practice
- 2 Millions Recovered For Injured Clients
- 3 Every Case Prepared For Trial
Tell us what happened and we will respond promptly.
Practice Areas
- Personal Injury
- Bicycle Accidents
- Car Accidents
- Motorcycle Accidents
- Pedestrian Accidents
- Premises Liability
- Slip and Falls
- Truck Accidents
- Workers’ Compensation
- Wrongful Death
Posted on Google![]()
Franz A0 days agoTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Excellent service. Case settled.Posted on Google![]()
Yadiesda M15 days agoTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Mi experiencia con el abogado Jared Newman,fue excelente al igual que con Jessi,me mantuvo al corriente del caso,siempre me aclaraba mis dudas muy amable los recomiendo al 💯 no duden en tener sus experiencias con ellos Muchas gracias Jessi y Jared dios los bendiga siemprePosted on Google![]()
Yashica S17 days agoTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I had the pleasure of connecting with Jared Newman through a referral, and from our very first conversation, my experience has been nothing short of exceptional. His team has been incredibly responsive, professional, and attentive throughout the entire process, always making sure I had the correct information and keeping communication clear and consistent. I also had the opportunity to work with Dayana and Sarah, who were absolutely wonderful! They were attentive, helpful, and quick to address my needs. I never had to deal with long hold times, or negative attitudes. They made the entire experience smooth and stress-free. The level of professionalism, communication, and customer service I received from Jared Newman and his team truly exceeded my expectations. I highly recommend this law firm to anyone looking for a knowledgeable, responsive, and genuinely caring team!+0Posted on Google![]()
Naysha B22 days agoTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Jared, Dayana, Sarah and everybody at Newman and Law, thank you all for being professional, transparent, honest and informative throughout my whole process. You all definitely did a 5 star job 🙏🏾Posted on Google![]()
Odoardo T37 days agoTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
El abogado Jared es excelente mi caso lo llevo muy bien es un abogado con un excelente toque humano entiende los problemas del caso y lo atiende muy bien y sin dejar por Aldo a Dayana super recomendadosPosted on Google![]()
Junior C80 days agoTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
The Newman law firm was nothing but professional, reassuring and supportive! I highly recommend the Newman injury law firm. Quick responses , communication was nothing but helpful.Posted on Google![]()
Son G85 days agoTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I highly recommend Mr Jared Newman.He’s very knowledgeable very helpful very patient very professional.My husband and I had a great experience with Mr Newman. We definitely highly recommend him, he’s a very good Lawyer.Posted on Google![]()
Erick S86 days agoTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Excellent experience with Newman Injury Law. The team was professional, responsive, and supportive throughout my case. They explained everything clearly and worked hard to protect my best interests. I highly recommend Newman Injury Law to anyone needing help after a car accident.Posted on Google![]()
Elvis A89 days agoTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Me sientonconplacido y completamente bien por el correcto y profecional servicio de los abogados, por su calor humano y el seguimiento de su caso, principalmente de Dayana y Jared, que Dios los bendiga y los siga por el camino del bien por su gran trabajo y apoyo 🙏Posted on Google![]()
Fernando M92 days agoTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Estoy muy satisfecho por la toda la ayuda que obtuve de Newman Injury Law, PLLC , siempre acompañándome en el proceso y claros en todo momento. Especial agradecimiento a Jessi, siempre estuvo diapuesta a responder todas mis preguntas y todo el proceso lo hizo parecer sencillo. 100% recomendado Newman Injury Law, PLLC.
Newman Injury Law, PLLC
Fighting for Florida injury victims, with millions recovered in verdicts and settlements.