To every client.

Most motorcycle riders have dealt with some type of injury before. Maybe you've had back pain from an old workplace incident, a surgically repaired shoulder, or chronic neck issues from a previous accident. When you're involved in a motorcycle crash, these pre-existing conditions can become a significant part of the legal conversation. Insurance companies love to focus on your medical history. They'll dig through your records looking for anything that might reduce what they owe you, but having a pre-existing injury doesn't mean you're out of luck.

The Eggshell Plaintiff Rule In Florida

Florida recognizes something called the eggshell plaintiff rule. This legal principle says that a defendant has to take a victim as they find them. If you already had a vulnerable spine and a collision makes it worse, the at-fault driver can't escape responsibility just because someone else might have walked away with less damage. The rule protects injured riders who were already dealing with health issues before the crash. Your Hollywood motorcycle accident lawyer can use this principle to argue that the other driver is liable for the full extent of your injuries, even if they wouldn't have been as severe in someone without your medical history.

Aggravation Vs. New Injury

One of the biggest challenges in these cases is separating what the accident caused from what already existed. Medical providers play a key role here. They need to document exactly how the crash changed your condition. For example, if you had mild lower back pain before the accident but now require surgery, that's aggravation. Your doctor should clearly state in their records that the collision worsened your pre-existing condition to the point where more intensive treatment became necessary. New injuries are more straightforward. If you never had problems with your right knee, but now it's been reconstructed after the crash, that's clearly accident-related.

What You Need To Prove

Building a strong case with pre-existing injuries requires specific documentation:

• Complete medical records from before the accident showing the baseline condition
• Treatment notes immediately following the crash
• Diagnostic imaging comparing pre-accident and post-accident status
• Doctors' opinions on causation and aggravation
• Detailed accounts of how your daily life changed after the collision

Transparency matters more than you might think. Trying to hide your medical history almost always backfires. Insurance companies will find it during their investigation, and suddenly, you've lost credibility. At Newman Injury Law, PLLC, we recommend full disclosure from the start. It's better to address pre-existing conditions head-on and build a case around how the accident made things worse.

How Insurance Companies Use Pre-Existing Conditions

Expect the insurance adjuster to blame your current pain on old injuries. They'll argue you were already hurt, so the accident didn't really change anything. They might offer a lowball settlement based on the assumption that most of your medical bills stem from pre-existing problems. This is where strong medical evidence becomes your best defense. Comparative records showing clear worsening of symptoms, increased pain levels, new limitations, or the need for additional procedures all counter the insurance company's narrative.

The Apportionment Challenge

Sometimes, juries have to decide what percentage of your current condition comes from the accident versus what was already there. This is called apportionment. It can reduce your total compensation, but it doesn't eliminate it. A skilled Hollywood motorcycle accident lawyer knows how to present medical evidence that minimizes apportionment. The goal is to show that while you may have had some issues before, the crash fundamentally changed your health status and quality of life.

Taking Action After Your Accident

Don't let concerns about your medical history stop you from pursuing fair compensation. Florida law protects your right to recover damages even when you weren't in perfect health before the collision. The insurance company will use every tactic available to reduce its payout, but you have legal protections on your side. If you've been injured in a motorcycle accident and you're worried about how your pre-existing conditions might affect your case, get legal guidance as soon as possible. Contact us today.